​

​

Ensuring Optimal PCB Design: The Importance of Early Thermal Analysis

​

Abstract:

 

Thermal analysis plays a critical role in achieving a reliable and efficient Printed Circuit Board (PCB) design. This paper explores the significance of performing thermal analysis early in the design process, highlighting the benefits of proactive thermal management. It introduces the fiXtress® Mini Thermal Analysis module, a powerful tool for estimating temperature rise and identifying potential thermal issues before PCB layout and component placement are finalized.

Keywords: Thermal Analysis, PCB Design, Component De-rating, MTBF, fiXtress® Mini Thermal Analysis

​

1. Introduction

​

Reliable thermal management is essential for ensuring the functionality and longevity of electronic devices. In PCB design, thermal analysis plays a crucial role in achieving optimal performance and preventing component failures. This analysis lays the groundwork for other critical processes like component de-rating and Mean Time Between Failures (MTBF) calculations.

​

2. Benefits of Early Thermal Analysis

​

Performing thermal analysis early in the design process, alongside component de-rating analysis, offers several advantages:

• Early Identification of Stressed Components: By proactively analyzing thermal behavior, engineers can identify components that may be under potential thermal stress due to self-heating. This allows for adjustments to be made before finalizing the PCB layout and component placement.

• Optimal Component Selection: Early thermal analysis enables the selection of appropriate component sizes based on their power dissipation and thermal characteristics. This prevents over-engineering with unnecessarily large components or using smaller components that could experience thermal stress.

• Cost-Effective Design Changes: Early detection of thermal issues allows for adjustments to be made to the layout before the PCB is manufactured. This avoids costly rework and delays associated with addressing thermal problems after PCB fabrication.

​

3. fiXtress® Mini Thermal Analysis

​

The fiXtress® Mini Thermal Analysis module is a valuable tool for early thermal assessment in PCB design. Since the PCB layout is not yet finalized, this module estimates the board's temperature rise based on the self-heating characteristics of individual components.

​

3.1 Functionality of fiXtress® Mini Thermal Analysis

​

The fiXtress® Mini Thermal Analysis module operates through the following steps:

• Precise Power Dissipation: The module takes into account the exact power dissipation of each component on the PCB.

• Temperature Rise Estimation: Based on the power dissipation data, the module estimates the "average temperature rise above the cold-plate temperature" (dT°C).

• Thermal Model Creation: Utilizing the thermal data and package types of relevant components, fiXtress creates a thermal model and calculates the dT°C.

• ​

3.2 Example: Applying fiXtress® Mini Thermal Analysis

​

Here's a practical example demonstrating the application of fiXtress® Mini Thermal Analysis:

• Scenario: PCB cold-plate temperature (T°C) is 71°C.

• fiXtress® Analysis: The module calculates the dT°C to be 6.4°C.

• Estimated Average Component Temperature: This translates to an average component temperature of (71°C + 6.4°C) = 77.4°C.

• Internal Component Heat Dissipation: The tool additionally considers the internal heat dissipation of each component (e.g., Tj = 83.4°C for component U3).

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

4. Validation and Conclusion

​

The accuracy of the fiXtress® Mini Thermal Analysis results is validated by comparing them with the temperature map generated by a separate 3D thermal simulation tool. The close match between the results demonstrates the effectiveness of the fiXtress® Mini Thermal Analysis module in providing a reliable early assessment of PCB thermal behavior.

​

​

​

​

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

By incorporating fiXtress® Mini Thermal Analysis feature into the design process, engineers can proactively identify potential thermal issues and make informed decisions regarding the component selection and layout optimization. This proactive approach leads to a more efficient and reliable PCB design, ultimately enhancing the performance and longevity of the final product.

​

Learn more about fiXtress®

​